Skip to main content

Q&A, Support, Working Together

We’ve started a forum over at https://community-energy.discourse.group to facilitate the ways we help each other and discuss energy transition challenges. The latest posts are below. You need to login to interact but the resources are available for everyone to view. We will build out the categories as we grow the conversation but at the moment you will find:

  • Resources
    • Local Government
    • Solar Panel Recycling
    • New Technologies
  • Policy and Advocacy discussions
  • The Community Energy Network for NE Victoria – let us know if you’d like to help develop a regional network and conversation in your area
  • Energy Nerds Bookclub

Please join in

  • Home Electrification Resources and Tools
    by @HeatherSmith Heather Smith on 18/11/2024 at 9:12 am
    Take control of your energy bills
  • Home Electrification Resources and Tools
    by @HeatherSmith Heather Smith on 18/11/2024 at 6:13 am
    Electrify Wangaratta’s great sign up to get off gas tool
    NB Victorians can also use the Electric Home planner
    And if you are really keen try the ACT Next Choice Electric Tool
    But for a more comprehensive audit, you can’t beat Ecologic
    Merri-Bek’s electrify everything messaging guide
    Seb Crangle’s Get your home ready for Summer
    Jenny Edwards and Lish Fejer’s Green it Yourself
    Energy Consumer’s Australia’s buying guides
    Renew’s Getting off gas toolkit

    What else have you come across that works?

  • Modelling the virtual storage ‘Ponzi scheme’

    by @HeatherSmith Heather Smith on 11/11/2024 at 11:02 am
    nickMasonSmith:

    Virtual storage is a financial overlay onto this physical system that moves value around but doesn’t create it.

    I think I understand your point but I keep getting tangled between the bit that does create value and the bit that doesn’t.
    Presumably the physical asset, any behavioral change from the household and any coordination between battery operation and the household are elements that could produce value.
    Part of the question is whether the household should be offered any value from the battery, after all they provide the surplus solar and they provide the regular peak usage.
    There’s so often a gap between the production of value and the capture of value – how do we untangle that?

  • Modelling the virtual storage ‘Ponzi scheme’

    by @nickMasonSmith Nick Mason-Smith on 07/11/2024 at 9:10 am
    Thanks for the reply Heather:
    I’ve deliberately abstracted away from community batteries to look at virtual storage in isolation. If we wanted, we could imagine another participant – a community group perhaps – that owns a community battery and earns wholesale market revenue, FCAS revenue, network export rebate revenue and possibly network support revenue. The latter two represent (or ideally represent) the benefits that the battery is creating for the system, and suggesting that these flow to the battery owner is consistent with the idea that the ‘agent of change’ benefits. As you note, community batteries struggle to provide a financial return to the asset owner even when all of these revenue streams are captured, let alone if that value is shared with local households.
    If virtual storage is a way to generate additional revenue for the battery, then it’s worth noting that additional revenue is not guaranteed. If the same virtual storage offering is provided to Nick’s house except both the load and solar generation are doubled, then Nick’s bill goes down and the virtual storage provider (retailer/network/community group) does so at a loss.

    If the subscription rate is the same for different households, then it stands to reason that virtual storage transfers money to customers with large solar systems and large evening loads, from either the virtual storage provider or other subscribers. A community group could conceivably find themselves with a subscriber base that adds another expense to its already marginal project.
    Community batteries can allow us to use our local solar resources and our network capacity more efficiently and force fossils to leave town sooner. Virtual storage is a financial overlay onto this physical system that moves value around but doesn’t create it.

  • Not permanent Solar installs

    by @HeatherSmith Heather Smith on 05/11/2024 at 1:53 am
    flexible panels! – CSIRO want your ideas

    abc.net.au – 2 Nov 24

    CSIRO’s new printing facility could put a solar panel in your pocket

    Solar panels that can be printed out like newspapers and rolled up to fit in your pocket are one step closer thanks to a new development by CSIRO.